Draw – Played 26th October 1958
Portlaoise 2-5
Paddy Bracken, Ned Wynne, John Keenan, John Dunne, * Tom McCabe, Alfie Lewis, Billy Bunyan, Phil O’Keeffe, Vincent Moran, Donal Dunne, Noel Delaney, Tom Preston, Eamon Phelan, Tom Phelan, Mick Donovan,
Subs: Christy Fitzpatrick, Tom Browne,
Rest Subs: Brian Stack, Richard ‘Sonny’ Brown, Larry Carey, Hugh Campion, Mick Larkin, Tommy Keogh
The Heath 1-8
Denis Conroy, Paddy Booth, Billy Hennessy, Tom McVeigh, Jimmy Conroy, Paddy Keyes, Jimmy Lalor, Sean Brennan, Peter Conroy, Dinny Rowe, Mick Browne, Tom Walsh, Jack Keyes, Paddy Crossan, Peter Keenan,
Sub: Brendan Conroy
Replay – 30th November 1958
Portlaoise 3-7
Paddy Bracken, Christy Fitzpatrick, John Keenan, John Dunne, Billy Bunyan, Alfie Lewis, Ned Wynne, Phil O’Keeffe, Noel McCabe, Tom Preston, Vincent Moran, Donal Dunne, Eamon Phelan, Noel Delaney, Mick Donovan
The Heath 1-4
Denis Conroy, Peter Booth, Billy Hennessy, Tom McVeigh, Jimmy Lalor, Jimmy Conroy, Tom Walsh, Sean Brennan, Peter Conroy, Dinny Rowe, Ollie Fennell, Peter Keenan, Bernie Conroy, Paddy Crossan, Jack Keyes
Sub: Jimmy Fennell
* Portlaoise lost the 1958 title on an objection by the Heath. An Illegal player ‘Tom McCabe’lined out in first game. Objection held in the Court House Portlaoise
